SEO Tools: What a Business Needs and What It Can Skip
Most businesses need fewer SEO tools than comparison articles suggest. The foundation is the search engines' own free tools, Google Search Console and Bing Webmaster Tools, because only they show data straight from the search engine. Add an analytics tool, a few of Google's free tests and an occasional crawler that checks the whole site. Paid suites with keyword and link databases make sense when competitor analysis is a regular part of the work, and their numbers should be read as the vendor's estimates. Google says plainly that third-party tools don't have access to its internal ranking data.
Types of SEO Tools
"SEO tools" covers several groups of programs that answer different questions. Before picking a product name, it helps to know which group it belongs to and what data it can provide.
- Search engine tools. Google Search Console and Bing Webmaster Tools show how a given search engine sees the site: what it indexes, which queries it shows the site for and which errors it finds.
- Analytics. An analytics tool, such as Google Analytics 4, shows what people do after they land on the site.
- Single-page tests. Google's free tests check one thing on one URL: structured data, performance, the indexed version.
- Crawlers. Programs that walk the whole site like a bot and collect technical data.
- Third-party databases. Suites with their own databases of keywords, links and competitor pages, which the vendor collects and estimates itself.
Each group provides a different kind of data, so they don't replace one another. The most common mistake is buying a suite from the last group before setting up the first.
The Foundation: Google Search Console and Bing Webmaster Tools
Google's Search Console getting-started guide describes the tool as showing how Google crawls, indexes and serves a website. The Search performance report breaks down traffic from Google Search by query, page and country, and the Page indexing report shows which URLs are indexed and why the rest aren't. On top of that come URL Inspection, the Core Web Vitals report based on field data, the Manual Actions report and the Security Issues report.
Google notes that you don't need to sign in every day, because Search Console emails you about new issues, but it's worth checking about once a month or after you change the site. How to read clicks, impressions and position in the tool is covered in our article on CTR in Search Console.
Bing Webmaster Tools is Microsoft's counterpart. Microsoft's documentation describes it as the place to troubleshoot crawling and indexing issues, submit sitemaps and view statistics for your sites. Bing also supports IndexNow, a protocol for notifying search engines about changed URLs, which we describe in our article on submitting changed URLs with IndexNow.
Google's Free Tests for Single Pages
Besides Search Console, Google offers tests that need no setup. The Rich Results Test checks the structured data on a page for features that can appear in Google Search results. PageSpeed Insights shows field data from real visits alongside a Lighthouse lab test. The difference between the two and which result counts is explained in our article on field and lab data in PageSpeed Insights.
For content planning, Google also has free sources of search data: Google Trends, which shows relative interest in a topic over time, and Keyword Planner in Google Ads, which gives an estimated number of searches. Neither shows how a specific site performs. That's still Search Console's job.
Crawlers: Reviewing the Whole Site
Search Console shows how Google sees the site. A crawler lets you check the site's state on demand, at any time, for example before a migration or after a new template goes live. It moves from link to link and collects data about every URL.
Screaming Frog SEO Spider is one example. A typical crawler flags broken links and server errors, redirects including chains and loops, missing or duplicate titles and descriptions, and duplicate content.
A crawler doesn't replace Search Console, because it doesn't know what Google has actually indexed. It shows what a bot can find, which is why the two sources are best read together.
Paid Keyword and Link Databases
Suites such as Ahrefs or Semrush build their own databases: estimated search volumes, keyword difficulty, link profiles and competitor traffic. That data is useful for competitor analysis and for finding topics the site doesn't cover yet.
It's important to remember where those numbers come from. Google's guidance on third-party SEO tools says third-party tools don't have access to Google's internal ranking data and can't guarantee performance, and that any predictions are their own and, like predictions generally, may not happen. The same page encourages using Search Console whether or not you use other tools.
The practical conclusion: "domain strength" scores and traffic estimates from these databases are the vendor's metrics, not Google's. They work well for comparisons within a single tool and poorly as goals in themselves.
What You Can Skip
Several suites with the same scope. Two paid keyword and link databases rarely give you twice the insight. More often they give you two different estimates of the same number and a debate about which is closer to the truth.
Daily rank tracking for a small set of keywords. Search Console shows the average position for queries the site appears for. For a business watching a few dozen keywords, a separate daily tracker often adds nothing you can't read from Search Console over a week or a month.
Services "approved by Google." Google's guidelines say it doesn't evaluate third-party services, so claims of Google approval deserve caution. That includes tools that generate "SEO-optimized" content and tools promising visibility in AI answers. Using a tool doesn't guarantee ranking success.
A score as the goal. An "SEO score" in a suite or a Lighthouse score is a diagnostic signal, not a measure of results. Results show up in Search Console and in the number of inquiries from customers.
How We Choose Tools in Audits
Search engine data first. We start an audit with Search Console and, if it's set up, Bing Webmaster Tools, and only then turn to third-party databases. In audits we regularly see businesses paying for an extensive suite while their Search Console property isn't verified or hasn't been opened in months.
A crawl of the whole site, not a sample. In a technical audit we crawl the entire site and compare the results with the Page indexing report in Search Console, because only that comparison shows URLs the bot finds that Google skips, and the other way around.
Third-party numbers carry a label. When a figure from a third-party database appears in a report, such as a traffic estimate or the number of referring domains, we label it with the tool's name and the date it was read, so no one mistakes it for Google data.
Tools fit the work, not the other way around. A small business with one local service usually does fine with free tools. We recommend a paid suite when regular competitor and link analysis is part of the scope of work.
Summary
A business needs the search engines' own tools first: Google Search Console and Bing Webmaster Tools, because only they show data straight from the search engine. Add an analytics tool, Google's free single-page tests and an occasional crawler to review the whole site. Paid keyword and link databases are useful for competitor analysis, but their numbers are the vendor's estimates, not Google data. Duplicate suites, daily rank tracking at small scale and services claiming Google approval are often unnecessary.
We choose tools and work with their data as part of our SEO service. If you want to find out what your site really needs, get a quote.