Skip to content
arduralab
·9 min

Choosing a GEO or AI SEO Agency: Criteria, Not Rankings

GEOAI searchAI OverviewsSEO strategy
MG
Marcin Godula

Współzałożyciel & Head of SEO/Tech

Specjalista SEO, GEO i web development z ponad 15-letnim doświadczeniem. Pomaga firmom B2B budować widoczność w wyszukiwarkach klasycznych i AI.

You choose a GEO or AI SEO agency by how it works, not by where it sits in a ranking. Google says plainly that from its perspective, optimizing for generative AI search is still SEO, so a good GEO agency has to be good at SEO first. Its recommendations should rest on official documentation rather than on "AI hacks" that Google lists as unnecessary. A guaranteed place in AI answers, inauthentic mentions and no clear measurement method all rule an agency out. Below are the criteria, the questions to ask before signing and what a report should look like.

What a GEO Agency Does

GEO (generative engine optimization) and AEO (answer engine optimization) are names for work on visibility in AI-generated answers: AI Overviews and AI Mode in Google, ChatGPT search, Perplexity and Copilot. A GEO agency's job is to make sure a company's site is accessible to these systems, understandable to them and worth surfacing as a source.

The most important sentence on the subject comes from Google itself. In its guide to optimizing for generative AI features, Google explains that its AI features are rooted in its core ranking and quality systems, and that from Google Search's perspective, optimizing for generative AI search is still SEO. In practice, a GEO agency without real skills in indexing, technical work and content has nothing to sell.

Outside Google, each system sets its own rules. OpenAI's crawler documentation, for example, says that sites opted out of OAI-SearchBot won't be shown in ChatGPT search answers. A good agency knows rules like these for every system its contract covers. We compare the two disciplines in more detail in SEO vs GEO.

Why an Agency Ranking Doesn't Settle the Choice

"Best agency" lists are a convenient place to start, but they answer a different question from the one a company looking for a partner is asking. A ranking measures agencies by its author's criteria, which aren't always disclosed, and even an honest ranking can't tell you whether a given agency knows your industry, your market and your constraints. In GEO the gap is wider still, because the field is young and many firms have added it to their offer only recently.

Google's guide Do you need an SEO? suggests a different approach: interview the candidate, ask for examples of previous work and talk to past clients. The same guide now lists optimizing for generative AI among the services SEO agencies can legitimately provide. Rather than comparing places on a list, compare how several agencies answer the same questions. The difference in quality usually shows in the first conversation.

What Google Says About AEO and GEO Services

Google has a separate page on evaluating third-party SEO tools, services and advice, and it names "AEO" and "GEO" services and tools explicitly. The test is simple: good advice either qualifies its claims as opinion based on data or experience, or backs them up with official guidance. Google also points out that it doesn't evaluate third-party services, so any claim that something is "approved" by Google deserves suspicion.

In its guide to generative AI features, Google lists things you don't need to worry about. You don't need llms.txt files or other special files and markup, because Google Search doesn't use them. You don't need to break content into tiny chunks or rewrite it specifically for AI. Inauthentic mentions across the web aren't as helpful as they might seem, and structured data isn't required, although it's still worth using for rich results.

That list makes a good test of an offer. If the core of a GEO package is an llms.txt file, "AI formatting" and bought mentions, then in Google the package rests on things Google itself describes as unnecessary or ineffective.

Promises That Rule an Agency Out

The first red flag is a guarantee. Google says no one can guarantee a number one ranking in its results and warns about firms that claim a "special relationship" with Google. AI features work the same way: Google's documentation on AI features and your website notes that meeting every requirement doesn't mean a page will be indexed and shown. An agency that promises a permanent place in an assistant's answer is promising something it doesn't control.

The second red flag is manufactured mentions. Publishing content on someone else's domain mainly to exploit its ranking signals is what Google calls site reputation abuse, and we cover the line between that and an honest brand presence beyond your own site in our article on parasite SEO. Creating separate pages for every variation of a question, primarily to manipulate rankings or AI responses, is something Google treats as a violation of its scaled content abuse policy.

The third red flag is secrecy. Google advises caution with any firm that won't clearly explain what it intends to do, and reminds site owners that they're ultimately responsible for the actions of the companies they hire.

Questions to Ask a GEO Agency Before Signing

Google's guide includes a list of questions for a prospective SEO. Most of them carry over to GEO well, and a few are worth adding because they concern systems outside Google. The criteria it shares with choosing an SEO provider, such as examples of past work, a clear scope and the way results are reported, are covered in more detail in our guide on how to choose an SEO agency.

What do you base your recommendations on? A good answer points to documentation from Google, OpenAI or Microsoft, or clearly separates the agency's own observations from facts. Google asks outright whether AEO and GEO advice is aligned with its guidance on generative AI features.

What results do you expect, in what timeframe, and how will you measure them? The answer should describe a measurement method, not promise a specific place.

Which AI systems does the contract cover? Google, ChatGPT, Perplexity and Copilot have different crawlers and different rules. It's worth knowing which of them the agency takes into account and why.

How will you check that crawlers can reach the site? Google lists making sure crawling is allowed in robots.txt and by any CDN or hosting infrastructure among its best practices. Robots.txt alone isn't enough, because a layer in front of the server can block the request, as we explain in our article on 403 errors for AI crawlers.

What access do you need? Google advises granting only read access to Search Console at the audit stage.

How an Agency Should Measure AI Visibility

In Google, the foundation is Search Console. Results shown in AI Overviews and AI Mode are included in overall search traffic in the Performance report, under the Web search type. Since August 31, 2026, Google has also made a generative AI performance report available to all sites; it shows impressions of links to your site in AI Overviews and AI Mode, broken down by page, country and device. An agency that reports on Google AI visibility without this data is skipping the best source available.

Google also warns about tools that promise ranking success or claim to use "internal" Google metrics: no third-party tool has access to its ranking or AI systems. Tools that monitor assistant answers can be useful, but what they produce is a measurement of a sample, not data from Google.

Outside Google, measurement usually rests on a set of questions put to assistants on specific days. Assistant answers vary, so a reliable report states which questions were asked, when and how many times, instead of a single "AI visibility" number with no method behind it.

What We Look For When Reviewing Someone Else's GEO Work

In audits we regularly come across sites after earlier work with a GEO provider, and the same patterns keep showing up. The most common is an llms.txt file and elaborate structured data sitting next to problems nobody solved: pages outside the index, AI crawlers blocked at the server level, or content that repeats what can be read everywhere else. The second is reports with a single "AI visibility" number that make it impossible to tell which questions were asked and when.

That's why we start with the basics: whether pages are indexed, whether Google's and AI systems' crawlers actually receive the content, and whether the content adds anything of its own. Google's guide to generative AI features says that content that's unique and useful to its audience will likely influence a site's presence in generative AI search in the long run more than any other suggestion in that guide.

We apply the same criteria to ourselves. This site has an llms.txt file and an llms-full.txt file that's built from the site's content on every build. We keep them with systems outside Google in mind. In Google we don't count on them, and that's how we describe them to clients, because Google says such files neither help nor hurt.

Summary

Judge a GEO or AI SEO agency the way Google advises judging any SEO: by examples of its work, by whether its recommendations rest on documentation, and by whether it clearly explains what it will do and how it will measure it. A guaranteed place in AI answers, bought mentions and a package built from hacks that Google lists as unnecessary are reasons to keep looking. Reporting on Google's AI features should rest on Search Console, and measurement outside Google on a disclosed method.

You can apply the criteria in this article to us as well. If you want to see how we'd work on visibility in Google and in AI for your site, request a quote.

Terms from this article

Need help with this topic?

Get a free audit and find out how we can help your business grow online.

Get a free quote