Skip to content
arduralab
·25 min

How to Choose an SEO Agency? 10 Criteria That Separate Experts from Scammers

SEOSEO agencypositioningoutsourcing
MG
Marcin Godula

Współzałożyciel & Head of SEO/Tech

Specjalista SEO, GEO i web development z ponad 15-letnim doświadczeniem. Pomaga firmom B2B budować widoczność w wyszukiwarkach klasycznych i AI.

You choose an SEO agency by how it works, not by its promises or its place in a ranking: does it explain clearly what it will do, show past results with context, give you access to the data, and refuse to guarantee rankings? Google says hiring an SEO can improve your site's visibility and save you time, but an irresponsible one can damage your site and your reputation.

TL;DR — Key Takeaways

  • SEO services in Poland are sold by everyone from one-person freelancers to large media houses, and the quality of that work varies widely.
  • A good SEO agency stands out through transparency, measurable results, and a contract that isn't a trap.
  • Red flags: guaranteeing position #1, a secret strategy, no access to tools, a 24-month contract with no exit option.
  • An SEO agency ranking is a starting point, not a verdict: check who compiled it, which criteria it used, and whether placements are paid.
  • Before you sign a contract, ask the agency 11 specific questions (list below).
  • Alternatives to an agency (in-house, freelancer) have their advantages — but also limitations.

Why Is Choosing an SEO Agency Difficult?

The SEO market in Poland resembles the Wild West. There is no single certificate or standard that separates an agency from an amateur. Anyone can start a company, put "SEO Agency" on their website, and start selling services.

This causes several problems:

Knowledge asymmetry — the client usually doesn't know SEO (that's exactly why they're looking for an agency). They don't know what the market norm is vs. what constitutes abuse. They can't tell a good strategy from a pretense of activity.

No reporting standards — one agency reports rankings, another traffic, a third "visibility" in an unspecified tool. Comparing offers is like comparing apples to tractors.

Long effect cycles — SEO works slowly, and results are measured in months, not weeks. This means you'll only discover a bad decision when you've already lost significant money and — worse — time.

Low barrier to entry — all it takes to sell SEO services is access to a few tools and a website with an offer. Someone with no track record can offer, on paper, the same scope as a team that has been doing the work for years, and the proposal alone won't show you the difference.

That's why choosing an SEO agency requires a conscious approach. The following 10 criteria will help you separate professionals from those who only pretend to be — and we've deliberately written them so you can run them against us too. We're an SEO agency, so we obviously have skin in this game, but that's exactly why it feels fair to show you how to check us, rather than pose as a neutral advisor with nothing at stake.


10 Criteria for Choosing an SEO Agency

1. Transparency of actions

What to look for: The agency should clearly communicate what they'll do, why, and what results to expect.

If you hear "it's our secret strategy, we can't reveal details" — run. SEO isn't magic. Every action can be explained simply: we optimize meta tags, we create content for these keywords, we build links from these sources.

Signs of a good agency:

  • Access to tools (Google Search Console, Analytics, Ahrefs/Semrush) — not only the agency sees them, but you too
  • A clear roadmap of actions for the coming months
  • Regular meetings (not just PDF reports once a month)
  • Honest communication of risks and limitations

Warning sign: The agency won't give you access to analytical tools "because they're their tools." Your data is your data — always. Reduce it to one question: do you see exactly what the agency sees? If the answer needs an explanation about "know-how we can't disclose", the answer is no.


2. Case studies and references

What to look for: Specific results, not generalities. "We increased traffic by 300%" without context (from 10 to 40 sessions?) is worthless.

A good case study contains:

  • The client's industry and starting situation
  • Specific goals and KPIs
  • What was done (strategy, tactics)
  • Results in numbers — traffic, conversions, revenue
  • Timeframe — how long it took

How to verify: Ask for contact details for a few clients. Google's guide to hiring an SEO gives the same advice: ask past clients whether the SEO provided a useful service, was easy to work with, and produced positive results. A good agency won't have a problem with this. You can also check the case study domains in Ahrefs or Semrush — the growth trend should be visible. If an agency dodges at this stage of the conversation, nothing in the rest of the proposal matters much.


3. Reporting — what they report and how often

What to look for: The report should answer the question "is SEO delivering business results?" not "how many links do we have?"

Report elementGood agencyBad agency
FrequencyMonthly + real-time dashboardQuarterly or "on request"
MetricsOrganic traffic, conversions, revenueOnly keyword rankings
ContextMoM and YoY comparison, trendsRaw numbers without interpretation
ActivitiesWhat was done, what's planned"We worked on optimization"
RecommendationsSpecific next stepsNone or generalities

A good report doesn't have to be long — it has to be understandable. If after reading the report you don't know whether SEO is working, the report is bad.


4. Contract — duration, clauses, what happens after termination

This is one of the most important points that clients often overlook.

Duration: The contract should give you time to judge results, because SEO works slowly, but it shouldn't lock you in. A multi-year commitment with no way out is a trap.

What a good contract should include:

  • Clearly defined scope of work
  • Measurable commitments on scope and process, not on outcome: the number and type of published content, reporting frequency, deadlines for technical work. Watch out for false precision — "organic traffic growth of X% in Y months" sounds like a hard KPI, but it promises something the agency only partly controls. We don't propose clauses like that, and we'd treat them as a warning sign rather than a guarantee
  • A short notice period
  • An ownership clause — content and optimizations remain with you after the partnership ends
  • A provision about access to tools and data

Red flag: The agency requires you to transfer your domain or hosting to them. After the partnership ends, they "cut off" your access to your own website. This happens.


5. Team — who will work on the project

What to look for: In the sales meeting, you talk to a senior. Who works after the contract is signed?

Ask about:

  • A dedicated project manager — who's your contact?
  • Team composition — SEO specialist, copywriter, developer. How many people? Are they the same people, or is there rotation?
  • Team experience — how many years in SEO? What projects have they led?
  • How many projects one specialist handles — and therefore how many hours a month land on yours

How to check this without taking anyone's word: ask for the number of hours per month assigned to your project and divide the monthly fee by it. That gives you an hourly rate. If it's clearly below the market rate for a specialist, either those hours won't happen as the contract says, or someone other than the person you're talking to will be doing them.


6. Audit before starting

A professional SEO agency doesn't propose a strategy blindly. Before saying "what we'll do," they need to know "where we are."

Good practice: A free mini-audit (or paid full SEO audit) before signing a contract. It should include:

  • Technical state of the site (errors, speed, mobile)
  • Current organic visibility (keywords, rankings, traffic)
  • Link profile
  • Competitive analysis
  • Potential estimate (how much traffic can realistically be gained)

Google advises giving the SEO only read access to Search Console at the audit stage, not write access. According to Google, an audit should give you realistic estimates of improvement and of the work involved, and if the SEO guarantees that their changes will get you first place in search results, Google's advice is to find someone else.

Red flag: The agency proposes an "SEO package" without seeing your website. Just as a doctor doesn't prescribe medication without an examination, an SEO specialist shouldn't propose a strategy without an audit.

The question almost nobody asks: what does the audit itself verify?

The mere fact that an audit was done guarantees nothing. An audit is a document full of numbers, and those numbers may come from a reading or from an estimate — and the document itself doesn't show you which. So we propose a sharper criterion than "do you do audits": does the audit have a verification pass capable of failing it?

Ours does, and we're describing it concretely so you have something to hold us to:

  1. No inference from indirect signals. We don't "estimate" metrics from what's visible around them — we open the source. If the source can't be opened, the audit records missing data, not an approximate number.
  2. A source register. Every number in the audit carries a URL as proof, a date it was checked, and the method of reading. Three fields, not one.
  3. An independent re-fetch. A separate agent reopens every cited address and compares the value against the register. Verification "from memory" is invalid here by definition — not because we distrust anyone, but because memory has no reading date.
  4. Separating repeatable sources from non-repeatable ones. robots.txt, llms.txt or schema will return the same result tomorrow, so we cite them canonically. An AI model's answer will differ tomorrow, so we record it as a dated snapshot with a reopenable link to the conversation — never as "AI says that".

And here is the part that makes this criterion checkable: the pass regularly catches something, and the things it catches are ours. Two examples from audits, both our own mistakes:

  • In a distributor's audit, a performance measurement failed to reproduce on the second reading — the interface returned a rate-limit error. The convenient number was already in the document. Rather than leave it, we wrote in a warning: repeat the measurement before using it in a client document.
  • In a design studio's audit, the first bot-access probe used shortened User-Agent strings and returned "no blocking". The AI model, however, claimed it could not reach the site. A retest with full, official strings — three attempts plus a control on three other domains — returned HTTP 403. The model was right and our first verification was wrong. We corrected the finding and recorded in the audit how we got there.

The second case matters more, because it shows what the procedure exists for: the first measurement was green and looked credible. Without a forced retest, we would have sent the client a document stating that their site was open to AI bots while it was returning 403 to them — the exact opposite of the truth, with our logo on it.

We have no documented case of a client choosing us because of this test. We describe it because it is checkable, not because it sells.


7. Technical SEO — do they understand Core Web Vitals, JS rendering

SEO isn't just content and links. The technical side is the foundation without which nothing else works.

Test questions:

  • How will you approach a site built in React/Next.js?
  • What do you do with Core Web Vitals — LCP, INP, CLS?
  • How do you handle crawl budget on large sites?
  • Do you conduct a technical SEO audit at the start?

If the agency can't answer these questions, their "SEO" probably consists of writing texts and buying links. In 2026, that's not enough.

We've written more broadly about technical aspects of SEO positioning in a dedicated guide.


8. Content — who writes it, what quality

Content is SEO fuel. But not all fuel is good — cheaply AI-generated content without editing is the equivalent of pouring water into the tank.

What to look for:

  • Who writes the content — a copywriter with industry experience or "someone from the team"?
  • Does content go through editing and proofreading?
  • Does the agency do substantive research, or just keyword stuffing?
  • What does the approval process look like — do you see content before publication?
  • Can the agency create expert content (not just SEO blog posts)?

Quality test: Ask for a few content samples written for other clients. Read them not as an SEO specialist, but as a potential customer of that company. Are they valuable? Do they answer real questions? Would you want to read them to the end?


9. Link building — ethical vs. risky methods

Links are the topic clients raise most often, and it's also where harmful methods are easiest to run into. In its spam policies, Google defines link spam as creating links primarily to manipulate search rankings and lists specific examples. Its guide to hiring an SEO adds that techniques violating these policies may lower a site's presence in Google or even get it removed from the index.

MethodWhat Google's policies say about it
Digital PR — editorial links earned with content or dataNot among the examples of link spam, as long as the link isn't bought or exchanged for goods or services
Guest postingLinks with optimized anchor text in guest posts distributed on other sites are one of the listed examples of link spam
Content marketing (linkbait)The listed example is low-value content created primarily to manipulate linking signals, not content that others link to of their own accord
Buying links, link networksBuying or selling links for ranking purposes, excessive link exchanges, and automated link creation are examples of link spam; paid advertising links are allowed if they carry rel="sponsored" or rel="nofollow"
Private blog networks / PBNSites with low-value content created primarily to link from them are an example of link spam
Comments, forums, directoriesForum comments with optimized links and links from low-quality directories are examples of link spam

Question for the agency: "What link building methods do you use? Can I see examples of acquired links?"

If the agency avoids answering or speaks in generalities ("we work on online visibility") — they probably use methods they don't want to reveal. And there's a reason for that. Google also advises avoiding SEOs who talk about link popularity schemes or about submitting your site to thousands of search engines.


10. GEO/AI readiness — are they keeping up with AI search

This is the criterion that in 2026 separates agencies of the future from those living in the past.

Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) is the work of earning visibility in AI-generated answers — in AI Overviews and AI Mode in Google, and in ChatGPT, Gemini, or Perplexity. Google's guide to hiring an SEO now lists optimizing for generative AI among the services agencies provide, and suggests checking whether their advice in this area is aligned with Google's official guidance.

What to look for:

  • Does the agency even know what GEO is, and can it explain where it differs from SEO and where it is the same work?
  • Is its advice on AI based on documentation from Google and other systems rather than on rules of thumb?
  • How does it check whether a brand appears in AI answers, and does it say plainly what such a check doesn't prove?
  • Does the agency use Schema.org for entity recognition?

An agency that dismisses GEO in one sentence, either as a passing fad or as work that has nothing to do with SEO, is giving you a slogan rather than information. This is the one criterion you can test on the spot: ask ChatGPT or Perplexity about the service in question and see whether the agency you're talking to even shows up.

One caveat about that test, following directly from the verification procedure described above: an AI model's answer is not repeatable. Tomorrow you'll get a different one. So a single run is not a measurement — do several, across several engines, and save dated screenshots. That is exactly how we treat such probes ourselves: as a dated snapshot, not a permanent state. An agency showing you one ChatGPT screenshot as proof of its AI visibility is making precisely the mistake we're warning you about here. You can find more precise definitions of all key terms in the SEO glossary.


Red Flags — How to Spot a Scammer

Certain warning signs should immediately end your conversation with an agency:

1. "We guarantee position #1 in Google" Nobody can guarantee this. In its guide "Do you need an SEO?", Google states plainly that no one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google, and warns against SEOs who claim a "special relationship" with Google. If someone guarantees it — they're either lying or planning to position you for keywords nobody searches for.

2. "We can't tell you what we do — it's our secret strategy" Transparency is the absolute minimum. SEO isn't magic; every action can be explained.

3. Contact exclusively through cold calls or unsolicited email Google advises being wary of SEO firms that contact you out of the blue, and quotes the kind of spam it receives itself: a message telling google.com that it isn't listed in most of the major search engines and directories. A good SEO agency has its own organic visibility. If they have to cold-call you instead of ranking for "SEO agency" — it's like a dentist with cavities.

4. Very low price Professional SEO costs money, because it consists mostly of somebody's time. Instead of comparing headline figures, run the calculation from criterion 5: divide the monthly fee by the declared number of hours and see whether the result resembles a specialist's rate. A very low price isn't a bargain — it means proportionally fewer hours. Our own rates are in the pricing.

5. 24-month contract with no notice period This isn't the market standard. It's a trap for clients who will quickly discover the service is poor.

6. No website or a low-quality website The cobbler's children have no shoes? In SEO, that doesn't fly. An SEO agency should have a website that ranks itself — it's the simplest proof of competence, and the only one you can check without asking anyone's permission.

7. They promise results "in 2 weeks" SEO is a marathon, not a sprint: results are measured in months, not weeks, and according to Google, no one can guarantee a #1 ranking. Anyone promising quick results is either lying or planning to use risky methods (e.g., PBN) that will give a short-term boost followed by a penalty.


How to Read SEO Agency Rankings

Read an SEO agency ranking as a list of names to check, not as an answer to the question of which SEO company is best. There is no "best SEO company" in the abstract: an agency that suits a large online store can be the wrong choice for a law firm with one office, and the other way round. Before you treat a place on the list as an argument, check five things.

Who compiled the ranking. Agency rankings are published by trade media, business directories, and agencies themselves. If an agency wrote the ranking and put itself at the top, the ranking is its sales pitch, not an independent assessment.

Which criteria it used. An honest ranking says what it measured: client reviews, awards, number of projects, search visibility, or a survey. If the criteria aren't stated, you don't know what first place actually means.

Whether placements are paid. A ranking can be built from paid submissions or promotional packages, and the list itself won't show it. Check whether sponsored entries are labeled and whether the methodology mentions fees.

Where the numbers come from. Rankings based on "visibility" or "domain authority" use metrics from third-party tools. Google says it doesn't evaluate or endorse third-party SEO tools and that these tools don't have access to its internal ranking data. Such a number is the tool's estimate, not Google's assessment. Apply the same caution to an agency that claims a "special relationship" with Google for SEO, because Google explicitly warns against such claims.

How old it is. A ranking from a few years ago describes an agency that may since have changed its team, its offer, and the way it works.

A few agencies from a ranking make a good shortlist. From there, the criteria in this article do the work: ask each one for examples of past work with context, talk to its clients, and ask the questions listed below. The same applies to rankings of GEO agencies. We describe how to evaluate a GEO provider without relying on a ranking in our article on GEO agency selection criteria.


11 Questions to Ask an Agency Before Signing a Contract

Take this list to your meeting with the agency. The answers will tell you more than any PDF proposal:

  1. What specific actions will you take in the first few months?
  2. Who will be my account manager? How many projects do they handle simultaneously?
  3. What KPIs do you propose and how will you measure them?
  4. Can I see case studies from my industry or a similar one?
  5. What tools do you use and will I have access to them?
  6. What does your link building process look like? Can I see examples?
  7. Who writes the content? Can I see examples?
  8. What happens if there are no results within the agreed time?
  9. What happens with optimizations and content after the partnership ends?
  10. Do you monitor visibility in AI search (GEO) and what do you do about it?
  11. Does your audit have a verification pass capable of failing it — and can you show a case where it failed one?

We added that last question after our own pass twice stopped an error that was already in the document (both cases are described under criterion 6). It's the hardest one to deflect with a generality, because it requires a specific example of a mistake — and an agency that has never found one in its own work either isn't checking or isn't recording.

Several of these questions overlap with the list in Google's guide, which suggests asking, among other things, for examples of previous work, whether the SEO follows the Google Search Essentials, what results they expect and in what timeframe, and whether they will share every change they make to your site and explain their recommendations.

The agency's reaction to these questions is just as important as the answers themselves. A professional will welcome specific questions — because it means the client is informed. A scammer will start squirming.


In-House SEO vs Agency vs Freelancer

An agency isn't always the best choice. It all depends on your budget, needs, and stage of company development.

CriterionIn-house SEOSEO AgencyFreelancer
Cost structureSalary plus tools — a fixed cost regardless of workloadMonthly fee — a variable cost, scalable both waysPer project or per hour
Scope of competenciesOne person = limitedTeam of specialistsUsually narrow
AvailabilityFull (employment)Agreed (SLA)Variable
ScalabilityDifficult (recruitment)Easy (change package)Limited
Industry knowledgeDeep (focus on 1 company)Broad (many industries)Variable
Turnover riskMedium (employee leaving)Low (team)High (1 person)
ControlFullMediumHigh
Best forLarge companies with extensive sitesMedium companies, complex projectsSmall companies, simple needs

When an agency is the best choice:

  • You need a team (SEO technician + copywriter + link builder), but can't afford 3 salaries
  • Your industry requires advanced strategies (e-commerce, SaaS, B2B) — or a specialized approach, e.g., SEO for law firms or SEO for healthcare
  • You want results faster than building in-house competencies from scratch

When in-house makes sense:

  • You have the budget for a senior hire together with tools — a salary without an Ahrefs or Semrush license is a specialist without instruments
  • SEO is a key customer acquisition channel
  • You have a large site requiring continuous work

When a freelancer is enough:

  • Small site with few pages
  • You need a specific thing (audit, migration, strategy), not ongoing service
  • You have a limited budget but want professional work

How Much Does an SEO Agency Cost?

As much as the scope of work covered by the monthly fee — which is why the price alone tells you little. At ARDURA Lab, SEO starts from EUR 500 per month (pricing). We don't quote average market rates here: we don't know of a reliable source for them, and comparing prices without comparing scope is misleading.

To compare offers, bring them to a common denominator. Ask how many hours of specialist work the monthly fee includes and who exactly does that work. Check whether the agency implements changes on the site itself or only hands over recommendations — in the second case, you also pay for a developer's time. Find out whether content and links are included or billed separately, how long the contract runs, and on what terms you can leave. Only offers broken down this way can be compared fairly.

How to Choose an SEO Agency for E-commerce

Look at whether it understands the problems a company website doesn't have: thousands of product pages, filters that multiply URLs, a changing product range, and product structured data. An agency working with online stores should be able to discuss these specifically before it proposes writing blog posts.

At the first meeting, ask how the agency will handle filter and sort pages, what it will do with discontinued products, and how it will implement Product and Offer data on product pages. Ask for a sample audit of an online store and check whether the store was of a similar size. Also ask whether the agency has worked on your e-commerce platform, because its limitations often determine what can be changed at all. We cover the technical side in more depth in our guide to SEO for e-commerce.

How to Choose an SEO Agency for a Small Business

Look at whether the offer fits the size of your business rather than being trimmed down from a package built for large clients. A small business usually needs a few things done well — technical cleanup, service pages that answer customers' questions, and visibility in its niche — not a lengthy monthly report.

Pay attention to three things. First, whether the contract has a short notice period, since on a small budget a long commitment carries more risk. Second, whether you know who will work on your site and how much time your monthly fee buys. Third, whether the agency can tell you what isn't worth doing at your scale. If you need a one-off job, such as an audit or technical fixes, rather than ongoing work, consider a freelancer — we compare these options in the table above.


Summary

Choosing an SEO agency is a decision that will affect your business for the coming months — for better or worse. Don't make it hastily. And don't skip this list just because you happen to be talking to us — the more of these criteria you verify yourself, the less you'll have to take anyone's word for it.

Quick checklist:

  • Check case studies and ask for references
  • Read the contract with particular attention to duration and exit clause
  • Ask who specifically will work on your project, and divide the monthly fee by the declared hours
  • Make sure the agency does an audit before starting — and ask what that audit verifies
  • Verify their approach to GEO/AI search, remembering that a single run is not a measurement
  • Ask the 11 questions from the list above
  • If you start from an agency ranking, check its author, its criteria, and whether paid placements are labeled
  • Compare several offers broken down by the same scope of work

If you're looking for an agency that approaches SEO strategically — combining SEO positioning, technical audit, and AI search optimization (GEO) — schedule a free consultation. We'll show you what specifically we can do for your site before you make a decision.

Want similar results? Get a free quote.

Need help with this topic?

Get a free audit and find out how we can help your business grow online.

Get a free quote